Let’s Dial the Way-Back machine to September 18th, 2007. Alberta’s Royalty review was released for all to see and read. The contents of the report indicated that we as Albertans’ were getting a raw deal on the Royalties being extracted by the various private energy companies that had taken up residence in Alberta’s Tar Sands. See the whole document here. (Catch a critique of the Royalty Review here) This is from page 7 of the Executive Summary.
“Albertans do not receive their fair share from energy development. The royalty rates and formulas have not kept pace with changes in the resource base and world energy markets. Albertans’ own the resource. The onus is on their government to re-balance the royalty and tax system so that a fair share is collected. This must be done within an equitable and flexible administrative framework that maintains Alberta’s competitive edge for energy investment.
The total government take (Alberta and Canada, taxes and royalties) can be increased with Alberta still remaining an attractive investment destination. The Alberta Royalty Review Panel recommends that the total take for the energy sector be increased by sector, as shown in this table.”
Current Sharing Recommended Sharing
| Current | Sharing | Recommended | Sharing | |
| Albertans’ Share | Developers’Share | Albertans’ Share | Developers’ Share | |
| Oil Sands | 47% | 53% | 64% | 36% |
| Conventional Oil | 44% | 56% | 49% | 51% |
| Natural Gas | 58% | 42% | 63% | 37% |
Okay, nothing unreasonable going on here. Consider Norway or even Alaska for successful royalty planning. Comparatively speaking, Robert Sheppard in his Reality Check article says: “Norway’s technique seems to be to throw virtually everything it gets from offshore oil into the fund and to try to live off the cream. Alberta’s has been to live off its royalties and, if there’s any cream left over, toss some of it into the fund.”
The Results?
In 2004 the Alberta Heritage Trust Fund stood at 12.4 billion.
In 2004 Norway’s Petroleum Fund was valued at 133 billion.
Way to go Alberta Tories. Squandering our money seems to be the mission possible of the day or more succinctly, preserving the profits of the heroic oil companies that rape our land. Of course when we hear it from our rightist lapdog media in Alberta, the Royalty Review is virtually proposing the absolute destruction of the energy industry forever and ever. Which of course, is utter horsepucky, but not particularly surprising considering how politically addled we are as a province. But really, I needed to tell you about this story tell you about this one.
Alberta Health Services CEO and president Stephen Duckett speaks to reporters Wednesday in Edmonton. (CBC)
Alberta will move hundreds of hospital patients to newly created community-based spaces over the next three years, the provincial health authority confirmed Wednesday.
Alberta Health Services told union representatives on Tuesday that 350 hospital beds in Calgary and Edmonton will be closed and patients moved to 775 community-based spaces.
The province has now confirmed the breakdown of bed closures in the two cities — 160 in Edmonton and 190 in Calgary. Of those beds, 20 in Edmonton and 40 in Calgary will be kept open this year to help with what officials called “emergency room pressures.”
The government also revealed that 246 beds will be closed at Alberta Hospital over the next three years. {…}
Do you think possibly that maybe if we had decided to actually get a reasonable amount of return for the resources we have in Alberta would we have to be closing acute care beds? If the Alberta Government did not actually have the the Oil Patches procreating member lodged firmly in its posterior we might be able to pay for the necessary Health Care of the citizens of Alberta.
So what does the enraged populace of Alberta do?? Do we march on the parliament buildings to protect our healthcare? Do we write our MP’s angry letters? Do we say to ourselves maybe we should elect a viable opposition to the government? HELL NO!! We elect Paul Hinman of the Wild Fraking Rose Party of Alberta in a by-election to show our displeasure. The Wild Rose Party is batshite-crazy further to the right than the current Alberta Tories. Make sure you check out their platform; or more succinctly, imagine every wrongheaded neo-liberal fascist clusterfrack policy debacle… their platform gives a wild-eyed thumbs up to them all.
The crazy is strong here today, and I am not liking it.




8 comments
September 16, 2009 at 10:27 pm
karen s
Holy obvious Batman? It is obvious to me the goose that lays the golden eggs was killed with our new royalty systems and uncertainties. It is also obvious to me that Mr. Duckett was brought in to erode the public health care system and therefore logically, privatize it and of course improve it.
The comment “fair share” is big. Anything is fair for royalties on a barrel of oil, from one penny above the oil company’s operating costs to all the margin from operating costs to market price. The difference proposed may not appear big by percentages, but it was big enough to undermine the economic assumptions for many oil companies and drive their investments to other provinces. Energy and resources income made up one third of our total income for govt spending. In Q1 2009 alone that income was down by $3.2 billion or 75%. Ed’s fiddling with royalties certainly did not help in this regard.
The government is comfortable in its sense of entitlement to a rich budget. They will drive us into debt because we “need” nice pedestrian bridges and other luxuries. What we really need is good leadership to make tough decisions like cutting management costs while increasing the budget for front line healthcare.
LikeLike
September 30, 2009 at 7:06 pm
Tnelson
Hey, I found your blog in a new directory of blogs. I dont know how your blog came up, must have been a typo, anyway cool blog, I bookmarked you. :)
LikeLike
October 6, 2009 at 10:04 am
Pardoxical Social Norms: We need more Police! « Dead Wild Roses
[…] Yet, I am the bad one because social programs mean taxes. The free ride conservatives give to industry also mean more taxes to pay for the average person as well. In Alberta, the royalty regime is laughably pathetic, with rates at absurdly low values. I digress as I’ve already talked about energy royalties in a previous post. […]
LikeLike
March 16, 2010 at 8:20 pm
Alberta Oil Patch Competition Review – Grab your ankles and hold on tight! « Dead Wild Roses
[…] frakking Unicorns back to our lovely province. Apparently the old royalty review was just too darn hard on the industry. Douche-Nozzle and Premier of […]
LikeLike
September 7, 2010 at 7:04 am
Stelmach, Pelosi and the Pembina Institute. « Dead Wild Roses
[…] “Premier Ed Stelmach is scheduled to meet with the Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, Nancy Pelosi, next Wednesday in Ottawa. The powerful U.S. Democrat is a key figure in the debate over energy resources and she wants to know more about the Alberta oilsands.” […]
LikeLike
May 10, 2012 at 6:20 am
Twinning Highway 63 – Socialism!!1!!1! « Dead Wild Roses
[…] the government, their interests should be protected first over the interests of private industry. Denying the government the money it needs to protect the people of Alberta is criminal. If we had anything even resembling reasonable […]
LikeLike
May 26, 2012 at 10:56 am
Calming Down – Putting Down Roots « Dead Wild Roses
[…] he should be ashamed for trying to keep the government accountable to for environmental legislation that is currently on the books, oh the villainy. The tar sands […]
LikeLike
June 12, 2013 at 6:05 am
Noam Chomsky on Destroying the World | Dead Wild Roses
[…] They get it. And we, fundamentally, do not. […]
LikeLike