The CBC needs a proper throwdown on alternative medicine. Alternative medicine is untested, unproven and most of the time ineffective. Does the CBC title for the story reflect this? – “Herbal medicine may be risky for kids.” Talk about a time to relegate journalistic “objectivity” to the sidelines. Presenting a ‘balanced case’ for both sides when one side is a dangerous illusion is irresponsible reporting.
“Giving alternative treatments such as homoeopathic remedies instead of conventional medicines to children may have deadly side-effects in rare instances, a new analysis says.”
Trying to cure ailments with unproven treatments is a deadly practice. End of line.
“Australian researchers monitored reports from pediatricians in Australia from 2001 to 2003 looking for suspected side-effects from alternative medicines like herbal treatments, vitamin supplements or naturopathic pills. They found 39 reports of side-effects including four deaths.”
You know why you only hear about the alternative medicine success stories? The majority that did not make it are dead.
“In the study, researchers found infants to children aged 16 were affected by complementary medicines and that in nearly 65 per cent of the cases, side-effects were classified as severe, life-threatening, or fatal. In 44 per cent of cases, pediatricians believed their patient had been harmed by a failure to use conventional medicines.
“We have known for a long time that alternative medicines can put patients at risk,” said Edzard Ernst, a professor of complementary medicine at Peninsula Medical School in Exeter, England. He was not linked to the study.
“Perhaps the most serious harm occurs when effective therapies are replaced by ineffective alternative therapies,” he said. “In that situation, even an intrinsically harmless medicine, like a homeopathic medicine, can be life-threatening,” Ernst said.
Embracing woo is hazardous to your health.
“Many of the adverse events associated with failure to use conventional medicine resulted from the family’s belief in complementary and alternative medicine and determination to use it despite medical advice,” Alissa Lim of the Royal Children’s Hospital in Melbourne and colleagues wrote.
They described one case of a 10-month-old baby who had severe septic shock after being given naturopathic medicines and was assigned to a special diet to treat eczema. In another case, an infant who suffered multiple seizures and a heart attack died after being given alternative therapies — which the parents had chosen due to their concerns about the side-effects of regular medicines.”
Misinformed, ignorant people paying woo practitioners to kill them and their loved ones. A deplorable state of affairs that could have been averted with just a touch of critical thinking.




11 comments
December 29, 2010 at 7:59 am
tildeb
You mean belief in CAM (complimentary and alternative) woo and medical knowledge are not compatible ‘ways of knowing’? Whoda thunk?
You must be another one those militant, strident, intolerant, arrogant, narrow-minded, medical fundamentalists! Everyone knows it takes more ‘faith’ to believe in medical knowledge than it does to believe in CAM woo. How dare you suggest the evidence of efficacy matters. I want to hear the ‘other’ (compatible) side in this ‘controversy’.
LikeLike
December 29, 2010 at 9:26 am
Tweets that mention Alternative Medicine - Killing Kids Near You.: -- Topsy.com
[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Progressive Bloggers. Progressive Bloggers said: #cdnprog Alternative Medicine – Killing Kids Near You. (Dead Wild Roses): The CBC needs a proper throwdown… http://dlvr.it/CJn6V #cdnpoli […]
LikeLike
December 29, 2010 at 9:47 am
shortbuswonderkid
I’d worked in the medical field long enought to know that contemporary medicine is still snakeoil, just with an arrogantly high pricetag. All that a hospital really does is numb you to a near coma, give you a breathing machine and violate every hole you think is sacred, and leave your body to do what it would have done anyway — live or die.
People worship it and covet it, but it is all just hocus pocus.
LikeLike
December 29, 2010 at 11:20 am
The Arbourist
that contemporary medicine is still snakeoil
Evidence please.
People worship it and covet it, but it is all just hocus pocus.
So doing untested, unreliable and unproven things are better? Good luck with that.
LikeLike
December 29, 2010 at 12:08 pm
Askeptic
I liked your post and thought you could use a positive comment to balance off the woo rec’d to date. I missed the CBC story as you can tell from my post at http://www.askepticrtn.com. However, it looks as though we both share a concern over the role of the media in promoting alternative medicine quackery.
Perhaps one day, the CBC and others will take their role as news organizations seriously. That should help reduce the number of delusional commentators to your blog and the death rate among children. I call that win-win.
LikeLike
December 29, 2010 at 12:25 pm
Alternative Medicine – Killing Kids Near You. « Dead Wild Roses | Vitaminsister.co.cc
[…] rest is here: Alternative Medicine – Killing Kids Near You. « Dead Wild Roses This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged 2003-looking, australia, from-2001, […]
LikeLike
December 29, 2010 at 12:37 pm
The Arbourist
LoL :)
LikeLike
December 29, 2010 at 12:44 pm
The Arbourist
Thanks :) – It is nice to see another Alberta skeptic in the mix. Even if they are from Calgary… (kidding, the whole dueling cities idea is pretty silly).
I was shocked at how easily the woo peddlers got off in the story and was compelled to write about it. More distressing was in the related stories link on CBC was a article about mainstream american hospitals endorsing Woo full on.
LikeLike
December 29, 2010 at 1:49 pm
Eleanor Cramer
I noted an interesting TV news spot (USA) last summer. Children’s cough syrup and other cold meds had been pulled off the market in 2007 because of being found to be either ineffective or dangerous or both. The news dealt with a followup study by the FDA which found that subsequent to the meds being yanked, kids ER visits related to side effects had dropped by half. http://jama.ama-assn.org/content/304/24/2686.extract
So, what was the focus of the story as reported by the anchors? “Now that those meds are off the market, whatever can parents do for their children’s colds?” The question sounded like parents had been deprived of effective medications, not saved from hazardous and ineffective ones.
They did report the bare headline of the report, but didn’t revisit it enough in my opinion.
El
LikeLike
December 30, 2010 at 3:26 pm
Vern R. Kaine
Let traditional medicine have more of a focus on diet and everyday foods’ role in healing equal to that of their focus on pills “curing” and I think we’ll see more of this “woo” go away. The problem is, big business is as much in our food system (see Monsanto) as it is in our medical system, so people are more prone to test (untested) alternatives. Medicine on both sides has become more about selling than it has been about healing or curing, unfortunately.
LikeLike
December 31, 2010 at 2:57 pm
Richard Dawkins on alternative medicine and the nature of science | Alternative Medicine Guide
[…] Alternative Medicine – Killing Kids Near You. « Dead Wild Roses […]
LikeLike