I’ve researched a little into the topic of Heteronormativity in our culture. It is a big word, but really it just means the structural framework of how we view women and men in our culture and the roles and expectations we define as normal and how these roles should be performed. All fine and dandy right? In reality, not so much. It does not take much to transform gender roles into gender stereotypes and beginning the process of ordering people into their “proper” gender identities based on their actions and appearance.
Being an outlier on the hetronormative scale invites a variety of negative responses ranging from quizzical looks and questions all the way to profane gendered slurs. Concepts like heteronormativity and Patriarchy, if you are part of the dominant majority, are sometimes very hard to see or even conceptualize. It is only until you breach a perceived norm (as a member of the privileged class, if you’re in the underclass you get oppressed by default 24/7) do things start to go sideways. I came to this little discovery point about twenty some years ago for something as basic as choice of adornment.
Having worn a gold rings on my index toes for some twenty years now let me assure you that I have received compliments all the way to outright hostility for a simple choice of jewelry. One of the most common responses I get is “Hey, aren’t toe rings for girls?” to which I usually reply to my (almost always) male questioner, “Hey aren’t earrings for girls?”. Which usually makes them stop and think for a bit as the realization that the cultural validity of gendered practices is not static, but rather quite fluid in nature. Okay, well I hope they realize this, but most of the time they, just repeat their first comment again (they having just passed a heteronormative judgment), to which I reply, “I think they look cool, and thanks for asking,” and politely steer the conversation elsewhere.
Less judicious or enlightened individuals have often questioned my sexuality dropping the familiar hetro-bomb, “Are you gay?” with the word gay dripping with scorn and derision. Does wearing toe rings make you gay? It has not worked yet, and I would not be particularly worried if it did because like most decisions of this nature, first and foremost it is my choice. And I choose the gendered slurs and disapprobation from various sources because when it comes down to it, it is their problem, not mine. I can come to this conclusion precisely because I am a member of the dominant class and still retain enough of my privilege so that my outlier choices do not negatively effect my social status much over all.
Still think that patriarchy and privilege are not integral parts of our society? Push your “normal” gender role a bit just to see, as an experiment, how closely heteronormative norms are enforced, I dare ya. :)
11 comments
May 12, 2011 at 4:59 pm
Bleatmop
I think I can relate to this, being a nurse and all. However most of the comments that I receive are usually positive, though occasionally I do get some negative feedback. Also, I occasionally I get questions like “Are you married” or “Do you have any kids” in thinly veiled attempts to try and get me to identify my sexual orientation. However, weather it is negative or positive feedback I am getting, it is still because I’ve stepped out of a traditionally male role and into a traditionally female role. Not that I mind getting compliments though, and it mostly is :)
LikeLike
May 14, 2011 at 8:22 am
The Arbourist
It still can be tough though. Running into the societies’ expectations on the wrong end of the stick can be very educational at times.
LikeLike
May 14, 2011 at 12:36 pm
Bleatmop
ARb – Agreed
LikeLike
May 14, 2011 at 12:41 pm
Alan Scott
Aren’t gender roles somewhat engineered by evolution to ensure the continuation of the species ? In birds of paradise the males have evolved elaborate ‘ costumes ‘ to attract mates , while females are drab .
In humans culture supplies the costumes which each sex uses to attract a mate . Nature only cares about how many offspring you leave that survive .
Our Patriarchal cultures are what has survived the evolutionary struggles until now . That includes gender roles and symbols . If these new gender specific norms you discuss are to take hold, ultimately they have to confer some reproductive advantage or the society will always revert back to traditional conventions .
In other words, you can’t blame people for being confused when someone violates the norms of gender identification . Unless your new behaviors become far more common .
LikeLike
January 14, 2012 at 2:27 pm
The Arbourist
Best search term ever for this post –
“does it make a man gay if he got a toe ring?”
Quick answer – No.
LikeLiked by 1 person
February 8, 2012 at 1:21 pm
Tracy
I own toerings.com and about 40% of my sales are to men. I think to each his own and it’s great that guys like wearing toe rings too! Some of our inventory is very masculine and the guys that like toe rings tell me that they love the selection. Check us out on facebook because a lot of guys post photos there.
LikeLiked by 1 person
February 11, 2012 at 3:05 pm
The Arbourist
I’m curious Tracy, as to the 40 percent of male buyers you claim to have – to the point are they buying for themselves or for another?
I guess, the other point I’m considering is that you post may well indeed be shameless self-promotion as opposed to genuine interest in the post.
LikeLike
February 12, 2012 at 10:58 am
VR Kaine
Just thinking back to my small town Alberta roots, and how much flak a guy would get for even having a single, pin-sized earring in his ear. Times have changed a lot, but society still has a long way to go, in my opinion.
I just watched “The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo”. Incredible story, in my opinion, so much so that I toughed through the foreign versions of the same series. People who judge and discriminate simply on the basis of appearance – especially nowadays – do so at their own peril, I think. Some of my staff would be considered “nerds” and “freaks” by others, but they are amazing employees and incredible people by all accounts (and actually come to think of it, they love the terms “nerd” and “freak”! haha)
So from that perspective I think, “A toe ring, SERIOUSLY?!”
LikeLike
February 12, 2012 at 11:28 am
The Arbourist
Times have changed a lot, but society still has a long way to go, in my opinion.
Oh indeed they do Vern. Indeed they do.
People who judge and discriminate simply on the basis of appearance – especially nowadays – do so at their own peril, I think.
We are all guilty of doing so Vern. We, being a social species, make choices consciously and unconsciously that affect how we act and feel around others based on the flimsiest of information.
o from that perspective I think, “A toe ring, SERIOUSLY?!”
:) Oh the transgressive nature of it all.
LikeLike
March 8, 2012 at 4:50 pm
Amy
Nothing wrong with guys wearing ankle bracelets or toe rings but your feet are VERY ugly.
LikeLike
March 8, 2012 at 11:14 pm
The Arbourist
I beg to differ ;)
But then again I may be slightly biased on the issue.
LikeLike