The fear women live with everyday manifested itself in one of the most horrific ways in New Dehli.
“The woman and a male friend, who have not been identified, were on a bus in New Delhi after watching a film on the evening of Dec. 16 when they were attacked by six men who raped her. The men beat the couple and inserted an iron rod into the woman’s body, resulting in severe organ damage. Both were then stripped and thrown off the bus, according to police.”
Their culture, like our culture, is a rape culture. Women are deemed sexual objects for use and abuse by men.
“Despite all efforts by a team of eight specialists in Mount Elizabeth hospital to keep her stable, her condition continued to deteriorate over these two days,” Loh said. “She had suffered from severe organ failure following serious injuries to her body and brain. She was courageous in fighting for her life for so long against the odds, but the trauma to her body was too severe for her to overcome.”
She is unnamed, she is dead. The existing (patriarchal) system tries to justify what happened:
“The tragedy has forced India to confront the reality that sexually assaulted women are often blamed for the crime, which forces them to keep quiet and not report it to authorities for fear of exposing their families to ridicule. Also, police often refuse to accept complaints from those who are courageous enough to report the rapes, and the rare prosecutions that reach courts drag on for years.
Indian attitudes toward rape are so entrenched that even politicians and opinion makers have often suggested that women should not go out at night or wear clothes that might be seen as provocative.”
Victim blaming is on the first page of the rapist’s playbook. It happens in India, and it happens here in North America. One in four women experience sexual assault/rape in our society – the same barriers in India are present here in North America that deny women justice and protect and promote rape culture. They are working on the problem in India:
“Nehra Kaul Mehra, a young Indian studying urban and gender policing at Colombia University in the United States, said, “We come from a feudal and patriarchal set-up where we value men more than women.
“We kill daughters before they are born. Those who live are fed less, educated less and segregated from boys,” she said with a black band of protest around her mouth.
Sonia Gandhi, the governing Congress party chief, assured the protesters in a statement that the rape victim’s death “deepens our determination to battle the pervasive, the shameful social attitudes and mindset that allow men to rape and molest women and girls with such an impunity.”
What needs to happen is like the following statement.
“The outrage now should lead to law reform that criminalizes all forms of sexual assault, strengthens mechanisms for implementation and accountability, so that the victims are not blamed and humiliated,” Ganguly said.
Amen to that.




13 comments
December 29, 2012 at 9:37 pm
Do You Know What Atheism Plus Is? You Should! « myatheistlife
[…] UPDATE: Here’s another voice – Lucien Mavrick with a post about the very same people doing all the wrong things. If you are wondering what real abuse of women looks like, go read Dead Wild Roses and their post about gang rape of women on the streets of India. […]
LikeLike
December 29, 2012 at 9:38 pm
myatheistlife
I linked to this blog in conjunction with a blog about other sort-of-related bits. I hope you don’t mind.
LikeLike
December 29, 2012 at 10:33 pm
The Arbourist
@ MAL
No problem. :)
LikeLike
December 29, 2012 at 10:41 pm
myatheistlife
Thanks… really like your blog by the way.
LikeLike
December 30, 2012 at 10:34 am
bj
I cannot believe how brutal the attack was. 95% of her intetstines gone, all for the crime of being female on a bus!
LikeLike
December 30, 2012 at 10:55 am
The Arbourist
@BJ
The crime of being female needs more attention. The women in India, more power to them, are not being quiet about this and are exerting pressure on their government to change the crappy laws they have now.
I’m getting more than a little annoyed at having to explain why feminism is important to *everyone* and it is not some sort of double X conspiracy to make men sad.
LikeLike
December 30, 2012 at 10:59 am
The Arbourist
@MAL
Really? Thank you. :)
We’ll see if that holds up after we have a little fireside chat about your disdain for Atheism+. Feminism isn’t the dark side of the force, just for the record.
LikeLike
December 30, 2012 at 11:09 am
myatheistlife
It’s also not the light side of the force. It strives for equality for one group, not all groups. It is by definition a force for inequality. Consider a room full of unruly children. Do you punish only the unruly ones while giving special treatment to the ones who were not unruly, or do you attempt to lead the entire group in a different direction. A direction of equal treatment and calm interactions.
Feminism is an attempt to use the carrot and stick method of societal change. A method which has been notoriously unsuccessful. Atheism plus is just feminism in atheist clothing.
I do not have to disagree with everything stated by feminism to dislike it, nor do I have to agree with feminism to agree with the idea that some facets of our society need change. I simply do not believe that feminism or atheism plus are positive forces for lasting and useful change. Their tools are inadequate and notoriously have been shown to be truly poor tools for creating balance.
We need change. We don’t need the same old methods simply twisted in favor of the other side.
LikeLike
December 30, 2012 at 11:34 am
The Arbourist
@MAL
Some issues with regards to equality are zero sum, the balance is in favour of one class of people and thus must be redressed to achieve a more equitable outcome.
Other issues are not zero-sum and can take a broad approach, hence the raising all the boats approach that you mention.
That really depends on the situation. With regards to children, emphasizing good behaviour and minimizing your response to bad behaviour pays handsomely in the long run.
I suspect you’re not really after the behaviouralist explanations of rewards and punishments though. But trying to make a statement about what feminism is about.
You do realize that “calm interactions” are fairly far down the list of effective ways to change society right? The problem with calm interactions is that often the dominant paradigm of society dismisses the careful reasoned dissenting voices. Thus more strident action is needed.
Please also consider that the rights we enjoy now were not given to us. They were wrested away from the oppressors of the day in long, bloody, viscous fights that many paid the ultimate price for. Power never gives away power freely, not ever.
Please give examples of the carrot and stick method and be prepared to contrast this with the struggle against racism and discrimination in society.
As a skeptic and an atheist, one should consider giving proof or citing a source or two about how successful/unsuccessful feminism has been.
You are certainly entitled to that opinion, and concomitantly, to be wrong as well. :)
This is the second time you’ve asserted this without evidence. You’ll need to back up your assertion with some facts. Also, what tact would you recommend for tackling an ingrained system of oppression that is learned from birth and is constantly reinforced by almost all aspects of society?
LikeLike
December 30, 2012 at 1:03 pm
bj
Atheism+ is great, but, some of the people can be a little hostile, when it’s unwarranted. That is *my* only complaint. Otherwise, I agree with their philosophy 100pct.
LikeLike
December 30, 2012 at 1:04 pm
bj
Oh, and I *heart* Ophelia Benson. It’s fucked up how MRA’s are so obsessed with her.
LikeLike
January 1, 2013 at 5:19 am
feimineach
My fear is that though this is about as horrific as things get, it will soon be forgotten and it will not bring about change. India’s rape culture is as entrenched as any other.
LikeLike
January 1, 2013 at 10:59 am
The Arbourist
@feimineach
I hope this is not that case. What makes me more optimistic is that they have less of the stultifying media presence (I could be talking out of my arse on that one) there and thus more community. Plus the media is still reporting on issue in a beneficial way.
I hope that the women keep the streets occupied and keep the pressure on the politicians, especially when the ‘acceptable grace period’ runs out and the powers that be decide that it is time to return to normalcy.
LikeLike