Cultural analysis at its finest.
“Cultural mythology is often used in this way to distort what goes on between subordinate and dominant groups. It enables dominant groups to avoid seeing how much they depend on others to perform disagreeable labor in return for the low wages that help make privilege possible. Members of the upper class, for example, typically are portrayed as ‘wealth producers,’ the ones who build buildings, bridges, and empires, even though most of the work is performed by others, by ‘little people’ who pay taxes and often live lives of chronic anxiety about making ends meet. Donald Trump, we are told, ‘built’ Trump Tower, just as turn-of-the-century robber barons ‘built’ the railroads and steel mills that made vast personal fortunes possible. Entire nations also indulge in this kind of magical thinking. In the United States, for example, we rarely realize how much third world poverty subsidizes our own standard of living. We like to believe that our affordable abundance is solely our own doing, unaware of how much it has always depended on a steady supply of cheap labor and raw materials provided by countries in which much of the world’s population lives in poverty.”
— Allan G. Johnson, The Gender Knot: Unraveling Our Patriarchal Legacy




7 comments
January 14, 2016 at 12:40 pm
roughseasinthemed
Ragged Trousered Philanthropists. Still apllies today :(
LikeLike
January 16, 2016 at 10:11 am
VR Kaine
This is why people stay poor – they read this and go, “Yeah, what a bunch of assholes!” and then from there do nothing different that day except read news and blogs to prepare what they’re going to bitch about the next day.
News flash for all the peasants – EVERYONE knows that the “hard work” and “wealth creators” line is bullshit, and by everyone I mean even those at the very top, too. However, it’s still nice to bitch about it all the time, isn’t it? Gets to distract us from the simple fact that the way everyone gets rich, or wealthy, or moves up from their social class without inheritance or lottery has been, and still is, through one way only – thinking ahead, having/building something that people want (or will want), taking calculated risks, and being willing to push ahead when everyone else out there (especially the common class) would have quit in order to put that “something” into the market. That’s what life rewards, and that’s what truly creates wealth and I challenge anyone here who tries to pretend that they truly don’t know that or believe that deep down – that in their own lives they haven’t risked enough, or done enough, or pushed hard enough to change their stars.
Instead, it’s just easier to wax on about “mythologies” and “hidden narratives” and just beg for someone else (a politician?) or cavalry that you know will never come, isn’t it?
I’m alongside anyone blaming the big corporations that rape and pillage not only workers but cultures as well. Thing is, though, if I was REALLY against all of it I’d pack up my life here and go live with the villagers in Paupa New Guinea, for instance, and take up a real fight against Exxon/Mobil and the horrendous atrocities they’re committing there in the name of Capitalism. http://www.vice.com/read/papua-new-guinea-is-cursed
Why don’t I, though? Two reasons:
1) I don’t want to give up all the comforts I have here – just as I imagine the rest of you don’t – which makes me bitching about what Exxon/Mobil’s doing in PNG not only gutless and hypocritical, but also useless.
2) There’s enough people in any of these poverty-stricken countries that if they truly wanted to, they’d rise up and overtake these power barons and by sheer numbers they’d win. A bunch of peacenick pacifists ousted the British Empire. A small group of Afghan peasants have defeated the Russian Army and held off the American Army as well. Monarchies everywhere have been overthrown, but only by those who can think ahead, have/build something that people want (or will want), take calculated risks, and be willing to push ahead when everyone else out there (especially the common class) would have quit. Take any story of massive, humanistic change ever, and those are the common denominators.
So yeah, the rich are assholes. What now, “Fair Share” Liberals? Intellectualize more? Blog some more? Or is anyone going to actually do something themselves and leadership-wise to change the class structure you all pretend to loathe so much?
LikeLike
January 16, 2016 at 12:40 pm
The Arbourist
@Vern
https://youtu.be/6JErESW-CQI
Lol.
LikeLike
January 16, 2016 at 8:11 pm
The Arbourist
@Vern
You know Vern, I stop reading whenever I see the words “fair” and “share” in your comments.
Just sayn’
LikeLike
January 17, 2016 at 7:05 pm
VR Kaine
Newsflash, Arb – success isn’t reserved for white people. No Mexican millionaires? Indian? Pakistani? Asian? Black? Chinese?
And a 400 year head start? You so want to chalk that up to white oppression, but you might as well insert your hate for religion here instead because that’s been a much stronger oppressor of wealth and upward mobility in places like China, Egypt, India than white people have. What, were white people making Mao keep peasants poor and uneducated in the rice patties?
And as for Mr. Wise, all he’s doing is capitalizing on a market niche in a unique way like I’ve said, having the guts to truly take risks, and ultimately raking it in knowing all you libbies will keep him booked long past the 600 paid speaking gigs he’s had up to now.
And NOW it’s OK for a white guy to lecture on racism? Now a white guy can talk about how shitty people of other races (supposedly) have it? Can you guys get any more hypocritical? So amazing how easily a Liberals’ rules go right out the window when they find a new poster boy getting any sort of traction. I watched how you gushed over Thunderf00t, too, when he was talking your kind of atheism. How’s that hero of yours doing?
Anyways, whatever any of these “heroes” say, no matter what it will end up in the “So what, now what?” pile where FSL’s will continue to be the puppets and those who they continue to whine about will stay being the puppetmasters and gold-keepers at the top.
Why don’t you start a series of podcasts? Paid videos? Why not take a risk and start a business doing the blogging and articulating that I think you’re very good at? Why not grab some guts and take a leadership role, and put yourself out there? If you’re white and therefore have so many advantages at your feet, why not put them to use?
LikeLike
January 17, 2016 at 7:24 pm
VR Kaine
Surprised you even start reading those rants, Arb! I’m slinging some serious mud in them! :)
Not offended, though, and not surprised that you stop reading since “avoid” is pretty much the expected goto move with FSL’s when it comes to talking about any kind of Leadership and Risk. (Haha – couldn’t resist!) ;)
Thing is, though, I actually give most in “helper professions” a pass in those rants. People in those professions (at least many of them) – in my opinion – are often risking, struggling, and leading which I admire and more than that, they are unfortunately stuck in a bureaucracy they had to knowingly and unfortunately climb into in order to follow their passion and answer their calling. Those in other professions, though? The opposite. Most just sit on their ass and whine (even those at the top of the corporate ladder, for that matter). That is not action, not leadership, and not stepping up and to me that’s not doing much more than being pathetic.
I’m fine with continuing to be called out on my views, and I appreciate that this is a forum where even if I’m ignored, loathed, avoided, or not responded to, I can still call out what I think isn’t right and express (some) opposing views. For that, yours is certainly one of the better blogs.
LikeLike
January 17, 2016 at 8:28 pm
VR Kaine
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/politics/just-62-people-now-own-the-same-wealth-as-half-the-worlds-population-research-finds-a6818081.html
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/8f9ea1e2-bba5-11e5-bf7e-8a339b6f2164.html
“Informed Global Elite Places Greater Faith In Institutions Than Majority”
LikeLike