Why does society work the way it does? Why is there such a disconnect between the common people and politics. Jonathan Cook examines the power structures in our society and how they work.
“Rather than thinking in terms of individuals, power is better visualised as the deep waters of a lake, while the powerful are simply the ripples on the surface. The ripples come and go, but the vast body of water below remains untouched.
Superficially, the means by which power conceals itself is through stories. Its needs narratives – mainly about those who appear powerful – to create political and social dramas that distract us from thinking about deep power. But more fundamentally still, power depends on ideology. Ideology cloaks power – in a real sense, it is power – because it is the source of power’s invisibility.
Ideology provides the assumptions that drive our perceptions of the world, that prevent us from questioning why some people were apparently born to rule, or have been allowed to enclose vast estates of what was once everyone’s land, or hoard masses of inherited wealth, or are celebrated for exploiting large numbers of workers, or get away with choking the planet to the point at which life itself asphyxiates.
Phrased like that, none of these practices seems natural. In fact, to a visiting Martian they would look pathologically insane, an irrefutable proof of our self-destructiveness as a species. But these conditions are the unexamined background to our lives , just the way things are and maybe always were. The system.
True, the individuals who benefit from the social and economic policies that uphold this system may occasionally be held to account. Even the policies themselves may occasionably be held up to scrutiny. But the assumptions behind the policies are rarely questioned – certainly not in what we are taught to call the “mainstream”.
That is an amazing outcome given that almost none of us benefit from the system we effectively sanction every time we turn out to vote in an election. Very few of us are rulers, or enjoy enormous wealth, or live on large estates, or own companies that deprive thousands of the fruit of their labours, or profit from destroying life on Earth. And yet the ideology that rationalises all that injustice, inequality and immorality not only stays in place but actually engenders more injustice, more inequality, more immorality year by year.
We watch this all unfold passively, largely indifferently because we believe – we are made to believe – we are powerless.
Regenerating like Dr Who
By now, you may be frustrated that power still lacks a name. Is it not late-stage capitalism? Or maybe neoliberalism? Globalisation? Or neoconservatism? Yes, we can identify it right now as ideologically embedded in all of those necessarily vague terms. But we should remember that it is something deeper still.
Power always has an ideological shape and physical structures. It has both faces. It existed before capitalism, and will exist after it (if capitalism doesn’t kill us first). Human history has consisted of power consolidating and regenerating itself in new form over and over again – like the eponymous hero of the long-running British TV sci-fi series Doctor Who – as different groups have learnt how to harness it, usurp it and put it to self-interested use. Power has been integral to human societies. Now our survival as individuals and as a species depends on our finding a way to reinvent power, to tame it and share it equally between us all – and thereby dissolve it. It is the ultimate challenge.”
To change a system, one needs to understand how it works.
1 comment
March 5, 2020 at 8:06 am
tildeb
Pure and unadulterated bullshit.
Oh, the system… the system that “almost none of us benefit from,” says the man who received the system’s largess to attend and graduate with a B.A. (Hons) in Philosophy and Politics from Southampton University in 1987, who used funding from the public dime to go on to abtain a postgraduate diploma in journalism from Cardiff University in 1989, then continued on as a poor victim of the system who heard the call to get an M.A. in Middle Eastern studies from the School of Oriental and African Studies in 2000 in order to vilify all things Israel… the victim of a system, don’t forget, that allows him legal protection for the free speech he needs to be a freelance writer busy condemning the Great Evil that is Israel, while defending and championing those who agree with him, the same victim and social justice warrior who champions all things Palestinian.
Yes, the man’s take on power that he presumes drives the injustice, inequality and immorality of the terrible system he supposedly abhors comes from comes directly wrapped in the bubble ideology of Derrida’s and Foucault’s postmodernism in all its glorious ideologically acceptable term-laced irrational idiocy.
Oh yes, let’s change the system because NOW we understand it through Cook’s perspective? Umm, no. Cook clearly doesn’t understand it or he wouldn’t be such a hypocrite.
LikeLike