I’m not sure where Al Jezeera was going with this piece but I do find it interesting to get a non-official look at how we treat our Native Canadians.
“In 2007, the Mohawk community at Tyendinaga, 200 kilometres east of Toronto, blocked the trans-continental rail line and Canada’s largest highway in protest at the government’s failure to address land rights and basic issues of survival within First Nations – including safe drinking water, which the community lacked.
That episode was a hint of the leverage indigenous peoples in Canada possess, as hundreds of millions of dollars in cargo was stalled by simple barricades placed across a rural stretch of the Canadian National railway’s mainline between Toronto and Montreal.
They are referring to the standoff at Oka, I did not realize that it qualified Canada to become home of insurgents.
“In recent years in particular, Canada’s indigenous communities have shown the will and potential to grind the country’s economic lifelines to a halt through strategically placed blockades on the major highways and rail lines that run through native reserves well outside of Canada’s urban landscape.”
You tend to forget about things that are not happening directly to you. I was stirred by the power of Shawn Brant’s words:
“The message resounded,” said Shawn Brant, a high profile Mohawk activist involved in the 2007 blockades.
“We are not going to live in abject poverty, to have our children die, to have our women abducted, raped and murdered without any investigations. We are not going to live with the basic indignities that occur to us daily. We would bring them to an end.”
Yah, good ole’ Canada. We keep our Native Canadians in a deep dark memory hole, we bring them out to apologize once and awhile, but once we are done with them; back to the hole.
Oh and while you are in the hole, we will forget about nasty little statistics like these:
“These root causes, these abysmal conditions for some of the aboriginal people are serious.”
There are more than 800 outstanding native land claims held against the Canadian government. And in many First Nations communities there is deep crisis, with poverty, unemployment and overcrowding the norm.
According to figures from the Assembly of First Nations, more than 118 First Nations lack safe drinking water and some 5,500 houses do not have sewage systems.
Almost one half of homes on native reserves are in need of “major repairs”, compared with 7 per cent of non-native homes.
Natives suffer a violent crime rate that is more than 300 times higher than Canada’s non-native population, while natives represent 18.5 per cent of the male prison population and one-quarter of the female population, although natives only constitute 4 per cent of the total population.”
If my people were being systematically mistreated like this, I would be mighty annoyed as well. The sad thing is that I’m betting most Canadians have little idea what life is like for many Native Canadians. The lack of information or curiosity is a hallmark of imperial populations who are fed only the happy news about their great empire and how amazingly benevolent they are.
Hurrah for privilege! Hurrah for the subtle racism that continues to marginalize our Native Canadian populations!
Hurrah for the invidious status-quo indeed.





11 comments
July 5, 2010 at 1:04 pm
Bleatmop
Thanks for bringing this up. This is a big issue with me and I’m always looking for more information. That dark memory hole is powerful indeed. I recently was having a conversation about the residential school with people in work, and not only was I in the minority about condemning them, I was the only one that though they were a bad idea and that didn’t think they should be reinstated immediately. Imperialistic attitudes are still alive and well here in Canada.
LikeLike
July 5, 2010 at 3:32 pm
The Arbourist
I was the only one that though they were a bad idea and that didn’t think they should be reinstated immediately.
Really?
That is a lobe blowing proposition if I’ve heard one. I was not alive for the 60’s “scoop” of Native Canadian children from their families, but I am alive for the results of that particularly vile social experiment. Broken people in broken families raising broken children. I work with just one small aspect of this ongoing trainwreck and it shocks me that others would actually propose doing it again.
LikeLike
July 6, 2010 at 12:00 am
Bleatmop
Yup, for real. Apparently, according to them, the schools produced well rounded people. I had to stop talking about it with them because I do have to work with them and saying what I wanted to say might make work a bit more stressful.
LikeLike
September 12, 2010 at 10:56 am
Vern R. Kaine
I know two former residents of those schools, and what they say went on there was horrific, as many of the “missions” were before them when the country was still forming.
LikeLike
September 12, 2010 at 11:07 am
The Arbourist
Our past is not as filled with sunshine as some of our history texts like to depict. Plumbing the depths of our history is almost never a encouraging experience. It does much to disabuse one of the notion that we have ever been the ‘good guys’.
LikeLike
September 12, 2010 at 3:20 pm
Vern R. Kaine
Human history is filled with that, not just political history. I still think we’re better than the “other guys”, though.
LikeLike
September 12, 2010 at 9:58 pm
The Arbourist
I think everyone regards the ‘home team’ as better than the other guys, Vern. :)
LikeLike
September 13, 2010 at 4:34 am
Vern R. Kaine
Really? Some of the posts and responses would make me wonder about that sometimes. ;)
Seriously, though, which G8 country would you rather live in based on its history?
LikeLike
September 14, 2010 at 10:57 am
The Arbourist
Really? Some of the posts and responses would make me wonder about that sometimes.
Almost like I was a self-hating “x” (canadian, american, christian,jew etc.)?
I know you did not say that Vern, but when I saw that sentence I immediately though about the labelling of people as self hating when they do not show the correct amount of deference to elite consensus. I’m often very critical of policy in my country and the US because, in theory, I as an individual can make a difference what my country says and does.
I will not however accept that we, by default, are the good guys and that our needs and ideas are privileged over those of others just because we are the self proclaimed ‘good guys’.
Seriously, though, which G8 country would you rather live in based on its history?
If given a choice I think that Germany of France would be lovely places to live. France especially has a rich and fruitful history filled with humanities struggle toward human rights. It is not all wine and roses though, of course (Algeria comes to mind) as all nations pasts are necessarily marred with events that they would rather not be remembered for.
LikeLike
September 15, 2010 at 1:02 am
Vern R. Kaine
I will not however accept that we, by default, are the good guys and that our needs and ideas are privileged over those of others just because we are the self proclaimed ‘good guys’.
“By default” is the operative phrase here, and I agree. I do not accept that we are the good guys by default, either. I base my opinion on our actions versus those of other countries (i.e. their leaders). We’ve done some pretty horrific things that I’m certainly not ignorant to, nor am I passive about them, but still to me by comparison I believe we’re better “good guys” than the others overall.
LikeLike
September 15, 2010 at 1:14 am
Vern R. Kaine
If given a choice I think that Germany of France would be lovely places to live.
Interesting… you do know that France is one of the world’s leading weapons manufacturers, and is likely going to move to a more private economy, don’t you? ;)
Seriously, though, they are both great countries for a number of reasons, but I still think one of the two top countries in the world is the one that you live in now.
LikeLike