We have a newspaper of record of sorts here in Alberta. I’ll be quoting from the Edmonton Journal to cover the amazing amount of stupid it takes to somehow think that vaccines are linked to autism.
1. They are not. [Pubmed, Google Scholar.]
2. See #1.
“One in five Albertans believes some vaccines can cause autism, according to a new poll that suggests a big segment of the population is wary about a perceived medical side-effect that has been widely debunked by scientists.
The telephone poll of 2,838 respondents found that 21 per cent completely or somewhat agreed that some vaccines can cause autism, compared with 61 per cent who rejected this view.”
Do these people read? Admittedly, not many people I know browse pubmed looking for the latest and greatest in papers dealing with vaccination, but when it is important as keeping the population safe from easily communicable diseases some use of the critical faculties is in order.
“The results mirror what Mainstreet found in Ontario, Saskatchewan and Manitoba. In each province, more than 20 per cent of respondents said they believe there is a correlation between vaccines and autism, a neurological disorder, said Quito Maggi, president of the polling firm.
A study published in the late 1990s suggested the measles vaccine was linked to autism, but the author, Dr. Andrew Wakefield, was found to have falsified data to advance his claims.
Wakefield lost his medical licence and the British journal that published the study, the Lancet, retracted it.”
So, there is no basis for this link. Yet shitty people are taking advantage of the credulous and the credulous being well…credulous continue not to vaccinate their children.
“The skepticism borne out of the study has been kept alive by countless websites making claims and by celebrities like Jenny McCarthy, who claims vaccines can cause autism in children.
“The issue is, that fear has been instilled in parents,” said Shannon MacDonald, a post-doctoral fellow at the University of Calgary’s faculty of medicine who studies vaccine uptake and parental acceptance. “If you understand the background of it, that a study of 12 children with fraudulent data has been counteracted by multiple studies with 14 million children, that sounds obvious.
“But that’s not the message that people hear.”
When did people dispense with critical thought. For sure you can be “open-minded” but without a filter critical analysis your skull fills up with teh stoopid faster than you can say “Jenny McCarthy”.
” Fifty-three per cent of respondents said schools should refuse unvaccinated children, compared to 36 per cent who held an opposing view.
When the question turned to child-care facilities, the results were similar. Fiftyeight per cent said unvaccinated children shouldn’t be allowed, with 31 per cent disagreeing.
A majority of those polled – 56 per cent – said parents should be able to decide against vaccinating their children, but 34 per cent said this shouldn’t be the case.
Despite some skepticism identified in the Mainstreet poll, most respondents – 61 per cent – agreed that a drop in vaccinations of children would have serious health impacts. Sixteen per cent disagreed, while the rest were undecided.”
Well the majority of people polled are not skull-shatteringly stupid. But there is enough stupid out there to hurt people. Child vaccination should be mandatory if you child is to attend public institutions. End of story.
OR… you form a fake religion so you can opt out with the religious exemption!!!! *facepalm forever*
Sadly, this is a real thing. Thanks again religion for going to bat for people who believe in made up shit. :(




7 comments
February 12, 2015 at 6:37 am
Brachina
Jenny McCarthy is funny and entertaining, but I’d no more go to her for medical advice then I’d go to Carrot Topp or Jim Carry or Dayme Waynes.
It just another antiscience movement like Climate change Skeptics movement, Anti GMO movement, AntiNulcear, AntiWind Mill and so on.
We really need to demand higher levels of scientific literency (not expertise, but a reasonable understanding of how the science or technology works).
LikeLike
February 12, 2015 at 8:23 am
robert browning
No argument from me here. Have your vaccinations, rely on expertise and statistics and get the job done. The only info that I don’t see addressed here is from 10 or 15 years ago that correlated the “convenient” combination injection w the spike in autism. I’m probably missing a chapter or two in this story but healthy skepticism is probably the only thing that kept me from being a statistic in Vietnam trying to hold back the dominoes or whatever. This measles cycle bandwagon is painting anyone not readily compliant as stupid, saying all the doubt is based on one tiny flawed study but it has the feel of a wagon being loaded and pushed along by the medical establishment and pharmaceuticals.
LikeLike
February 12, 2015 at 8:34 am
The Intransigent One
Another angle of the vaccines/autism thing, that I’ve been reading about more lately, is how totally ableist it is. I mean seriously, if the risk was real, what parents who don’t vaccinate based on fear of autism are tacitly saying is, I would rather put my child at risk of death, than put them at risk of autism. And I mean, autism spectrum disorders don’t exactly make life easy, but you’d seriously prefer a dead child over an autistic one? Very interesting.
LikeLike
February 12, 2015 at 2:39 pm
bleatmop
Nothing quite like saying “You know what, fuck all those doctors and scientists, what do they know about vaccines? I’m going to take advice on whether or not I should vaccinate my child from a porn star.”
LikeLiked by 1 person
February 13, 2015 at 6:25 pm
Rob F
As I recall, the strongest environmental predictor of ASD’s is Congenital Rubella Syndrome. Which means that antivaxxers are actually causing cases of ASDs.
LikeLike
February 14, 2015 at 2:25 pm
bleatmop
Rob F – The last information I’ve read the causes of ASD are still not well understood. While there may be a correlation link between congenital rubella and ASD I believe the evidence is still not strong enough to prove a causal link. While it may very well be a cause it could also simply be a coincidence or even an aggravating factor for an actual cause of ASD.
This could be though of much the same way as peptic ulcers used to be before the discovery of H.pylori. They used to believe spicy food, stress, alcohol and a plethora of other things causes peptic ulcers. All these things were highly correlated to people having peptic ulcer. However after the discovery of H.pylori they found that it was the cause the ulcers and all these other things simply made the symptoms of an ulcer worse after it developed. It’s pretty much the perfect example of correlation does not prove causation.
LikeLike
February 15, 2015 at 11:53 am
Rob F
This study gives an estimate of the number of cases of ASDs prevented by vaccination.
LikeLike