Political practice in the US often seems to centre around everything but the facts of any given issue. The pandemic being one of the most obvious examples.
So, we ignore the real-world material evidence of what Denmark is doing with their Corona Pass and continue to prevaricate in our approved left/right ideological ways.
Can we just be pragmatic for once with a touch of utilitarian goodness on the side? Wouldn’t that be nice?
David Rovics writing for Counterpunch describes the pandemic angle of the left/right folly that is occurring in the US and to a certain extent, Canada.
“So when it comes to public health measures necessary to get a pandemic under control, much of the public is skeptical. They may be described as skeptical about vaccines, but I’d say it’s a skepticism, if that’s the right word, that far transcends any particular thing like that. It’s more a generalized skepticism of anything the government — any government, or particular ones, depending — might propose.
The far right is horrified by the idea of what in Denmark is known as a Corona Pass — a form of ID that verifies you have been vaccinated and have tested negative, in order to be allowed to do things like fly in a plane with other people, sit down in a cafe, attend a festival, etc. Through widespread vaccination and the use of the Corona Pass system, Denmark has thus far avoided the fourth wave of the pandemic that is killing so many people, especially in countries like the US, India, and Brazil.
But we can’t do that kind of thing, we hear from voices on the right, because maybe the virus doesn’t exist, or maybe the vaccine causes more sickness than the virus does, or even if the virus does exist and vaccines are good generally, these vaccines haven’t been tested enough, and if they have, people shouldn’t be required to take them, because that’s an infringement on their God-given individual rights. Their freedom to live free means they might have to die free, which is better than obeying a government mandate. And then add to the mix the fact that the only government mandates in the US that exist with regards to this pandemic so far are completely piecemeal, local, and therefore ineffective.
And then from the corners of the left we hear that having information like our vaccination status publicly available to the relevant authorities is the next step towards total control of everything by Big Brother, and as soon as we all have submitted to the magnetic strips on our ID cards, the next step are those FEMA concentration camps that the Spectrum always agree are waiting for all of the dissidents. Which dissidents will end up in those camps would be the main point of contention on the Spectrum.”
14 comments
September 6, 2021 at 6:46 am
tildeb
Reminds me of this from 1963:
LikeLiked by 1 person
September 6, 2021 at 6:46 am
Steve Ruis
We are ‘Mericans; we don’t take advice from anyone because we’re better than everyone else . . . .
LikeLiked by 1 person
September 6, 2021 at 7:22 am
Bob Browning
This appears to be an objective look at different “sides’ of the situation and asks some good questions. Like any good argument in a debate, the protagonist can get a lot of nods once their premise is accepted. The assumed premise here is that there is a “pandemic” and that ” it’s killing a lot of ppl”. The 2020 stats from the WHO and the CDC don’t back that assumption. Deaths in the U.S. are typically .8 to .9%, appx. 3million, per year- 20 20 was not out of line and 2018 was actually a bit higher. All the authoritarian measures (lock ups, masks, “distancing”, etc.) were, and are still based on early 2020 computer estimates that have been shown to be exaggerated by many multiples. The colorful spiked orb we see depicted as the virus is also a computer simulation since the virus has never been isolated and identified. ” Cases, cases, cases” is the main glue to keep the controls and the authoritarian narrative going. The non stop message, ” be careful, be afraid” is PR 101 and over time manufactures consent for the erosion of personal rights while the 1% gets dramatically richer w increased control.. We can hope the elites are concerned about us serfs but no evidence points to that.
LikeLike
September 6, 2021 at 8:41 am
tildeb
Exaggerated by many multiples? Go to a fucking hospital.
LikeLiked by 1 person
September 6, 2021 at 10:57 am
Carmen
Tildeb, I suggested that yesterday. ;). I think he’s in the same camp as the person I had an unfortunate encounter with yesterday. Here’s the story: My husband and I took our ‘47 Mercury to our first Car Show as a participant. Being it was our 1st, we didn’t realize we should have gone much earlier. Hence, when we arrived there was a HUGE line-up for entrants. (I jokingly said to hubby, “Oh, that must be the lineup for chicken!”. After we were assigned a parking spot, we dawdled around until someone came along and told us we had to get in the Registration line. . .egads.. .that loooong line up for what I thought was chicken purchasers. We decided to take turns, as we knew it would be awhile. I took first shift and there was a woman directly behind me (we were doing the 6-ft distancing) and we chatted for a few minutes and then she turned around to speak to someone she knew behind her. It soon became apparent that both of them were anti-vaxxers (she was a loud woman, to boot) as I heard her say, “Oh, don’t worry – you’ll be able to purchase lots of old cars soon. Lots of people have got their needle and they’ll start dying right away – there’ll be lots of cars and houses available to buy!” They got a great laugh out of that. The conversation (heard by many in the vicinity, I’m sure) continued on about some of the foolishness Bob has mentioned above. ..head-shakingly hard to listen to. I had been there for about half an hour, listening to her nonsense and my husband came along to see if I wanted to leave and he would take my place. I told him I’d stay, as I had to go work in a booth at a certain time and then he’d be stuck in the line. After he left, a fellow announced the procedure of voting, etc., and said that the Covid protocols were still in place – that is, people needed to 6 ft distance and wear masks if they couldn’t. At that point, the woman behind me shouted, “Listen to that socialist CRAP – that’s how six million Jews died!” I was steaming. She wasn’t finished, however, and said it again, louder. Thankfully, at that point my husband came back and I told him I figured my blood pressure had had enough. He was much better at ignoring her completely.
These are the same people who, I assume, blocked off entrances to hospitals in Halifax last week – yes, it happened here too. Honestly, I am wondering how much longer we have to put up with this bullshit. It’s getting completely out of hand. It would be one thing if they just shut their stupid mouths but it seems to me that many of them are just gunning for a fight.
Here’s another story that happened not far from me in the latest provincial election. I had a friend working in the polls and she said they had a few people who refused to wear masks and that there was a polling booth SET UP OUTSIDE for that purpose. (It was a beautiful day) One fellow, however, insisted that he vote inside – without a mandated mask – and what happened? The Hall was cleared of people, including the poll workers, and my friend and another poll worker – both wearing masks and behind shields – accommodated the anti-masker.
Yes, really. :(
LikeLike
September 6, 2021 at 11:17 am
tildeb
Wow. The stupid: it burns. Still, very good to hear from you, Carmen.
It doesn’t seem like Canada anymore, a country once upon a time with relatively educated people capable of at least respecting reality. That is no longer the case; instead, we get nothing it seems but champions of ignorance through motivated reasoning and/or disinformation spreading the Gospel. This is an apologetic tactic straight out of organized climate denialism whose paternity goes one generation back to tobacco’s Merchants of Doubt. And the tragedy is that this bullshit works better now than ever.
Usually, such denialism is best exposed, attacked, and thwarted by humour and satire, both of which are now forms of blasphemy in the Woke culture and so comedians en masse stay away in fear of the Twitter mob. This, I think, has empowered the live demonstrators of the Dunning-Kruger-effect-in-action to come out of the woodwork and use the internet just enough to fill in their denialism with just enough cherry-picked data to make it SEEM that doubt is justified. What a sad state our education system has produced.
LikeLike
September 6, 2021 at 12:02 pm
Carmen
I am really hoping that is not a thinly-veiled stab at teachers. ;)
LikeLike
September 6, 2021 at 12:57 pm
The Arbourist
@ Carmen
I’m shocked that we have such a large portion of the population that is so mired in ignorance. The fact that we have terminology – anti-mask – speaks to the level of delusion on display. You may as well go all in and be anti-public health measures. :/
LikeLike
September 6, 2021 at 1:08 pm
tildeb
Curriculum and administrative expectations, certainly. A dumbing down… when universities find 63% of undergrads don’t meet fundamental numeracy and literacy standards (80% if colleges are included) for graduation of high school. Yet they’ve graduated…
LikeLike
September 6, 2021 at 1:12 pm
tildeb
So that’s part of the problem. But it takes a village to raise an idiot. And this where a combination of social media, tender feelings, and so-called ‘journalists’ who don’t vet their ‘sources’ create an environment where batshit crazy is considered legitimately equivalent to reality. This is the environment necessary to fool most of the people most of the time and no backup education and critical thinking to stem the lowering tide of stupid.
LikeLike
September 6, 2021 at 1:13 pm
The Arbourist
@ tildeb
I lost my Mom this march of this year. She lost her battle with a pneumonia that her body just couldn’t fight off. I did all I could to keep her safe at home as we tried to avoid exposure to Covid. Her appointments with her doctor were over the phone, and I’m pretty sure his diagnosis were as accurate as they possibly could be without actually seeing her in person. I made the call to get her into the hospital because the congestion and pain was keeping her up at night and the measures we had just were not working.
Our Edmonton ICU’s in February were full of people needing serious medical intervention to keep them alive. Thankfully they had room for my Mom and they did their best, I was the only family contact allowed because of where we were in the pandemic. I was there almost everyday for the three weeks she was in the hospital and when she was in ICU it was jam packed.
The pandemic was a very real thing for me and family, I can’t help but thinking it played a role in my mother’s passing as the pandemic made it much more difficult to access medical care outside of hospitalization. I’m left wondering if I acted too late in pulling the trigger to get her into emergency care when I did. What I do know is the risk of exposure to Covid at a healthcare facility did weigh into the decision making process and it certainly wasn’t a ‘hoax’ while I was in the thick of it.
It still isn’t. I’ll take the mask off in closed public spaces when we’re past the 90% vaccinated threshold, to do otherwise in my mind would be irresponsible.
LikeLike
September 6, 2021 at 1:28 pm
tildeb
This is the result of going along to get along and learning to accept the idea that narrative defines reality, that there are multiple truths, that the world is a constructed by groups more powerful than other groups.
The bullshit is now so thick that it’s paralyzing meaningful action by eliminating shame for being ignorant and excusing ignorance in the name of tolerance.
This is not an event; this is a crafted environment that you bet belongs first and foremost to not just a failure of academia but a complete capitulation to a anti-liberal partisan ideology not just equal to but far in excess of the right wing conspiratorial nutjobs. Our universities are Patient Zero for this virus of the mind that deconstructs critical faculties and supplants it with feel-good kumbaya mush unrelated to the real world but imposed on it. That’s why this vaccine is not mandatory; with enough grooming and social pressure and positive reinforcement and rewards, maybe the number of death threats against immunologists and medical officers and front line workers in healthcare will decline. More lollipops. Yeah, that’s the ticket. Fewer harsh words because, hey, words are violence, donchaknow. And the worst of the worst are those who criticize and cause offense.
Meanwhile, the Jim Bobs and Candis and Olivers and Emmas can sit at opposite ends of then political spectrum and agree for different reasons that those who respect reality are the fools and the problem. That’s where our education-by-internet has led us to today.
LikeLike
September 6, 2021 at 1:48 pm
tildeb
I understood very early how the pandemic was and is very real when we lost a coworker in March 2020 to Covid. Out of the blue. Also, I can appreciate how rapidly filling ICUs bumped all kinds of life-altering therapies and surgeries and the untold cost to so many of doing so out of desperate need. I know how difficult long term care isolation has been on many families inside and out but frantic with justified worry. Because I have ongoing access to meta data from CIHI, I can see in raw numbers what this pandemic means in actual medical effect and so I understand that to not fear going into hospitals before vaccinations were available indicates sanity… but that this sanity also puts those who must decide whether or not to utilize the hospital between a unstable rock and a very hard place. And that goes for both workers and patients.
So to hear motivated reasoning and disinformation hold as much sway as they do contrary to reality is very frustrating to me. We should all be so much better than this.
LikeLiked by 1 person
September 6, 2021 at 1:50 pm
tildeb
Sorry, that sanity I mentioned should be related to being afraid. Covid to the unvaccinated should be scary.
LikeLike